Lao Tzu, This site has done everything and more that it can to prevent trolling within RP threads. As much as there are a number of people who would be fine with an unknown element added to threads, or potential plots or stories, or having threads with PVP for the sake of winning a fight, and not for story, That is not what this site is about.
For the past Six years, I have seen this site change from a splinter group of a website long ago, to its on dedicated site that literally tops the Google Search list for "Star wars RP" In that time, rule changes have been made for the betterment of the Majority. Having literal thousands worth of accounts on the site, means that most of them, need to be appeased. Most, don't like that unknown element and wish to have a story written for the pure fact of writing a coherent story for the story alone. Not to win a battle, or to win a duel to make a resume of all the people they have fought.
What you are suggesting, is going backwards.
I know for a fact that what you are suggesting will find no light of day, or bare any fruit. Many people, myself included, would love to have this kind of setup. However, the site as a whole, cannot sustain itself off of the drama, salt, and the literal Chaos that something like this would cause. Out of all of the reports every year, most of them are likely due to discrepancies of a RP thread taken too seriously, or someone playing god, or someone entering a thread when they shouldn't have.
At the current state of the Site, its not going to happen.