Star Wars Roleplay: Chaos

Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Cathar: tail or no tail

Sha'so

Looking for freedom...
Not sure if I'm posting this in the right place. I'm sure if there's a better place for this, I'm sure a mod will move it. If so, thank you!

Anyway, Cathar; we all looooove our anthros, and there's even a custom race on this forum of fox people who, I might add quite enviously, have tails. So Cathar, do they have tails?

Now right off the bat I know someone is gonna say "Well they don't have tails in SWTOR", and I'm gonna call BS on that. Tail mechanics are fairly tricky to program, especially in conjunction with several layers of robes, and it's considerably easier to simply not add tails to a playable race. Hell, they got really lazy with the fur patterns; when you go to play a Cathar in SWTOR, any facial patterns you pick do not extend to the rest of the body, so if you have a nekkid Cathar then she's gonna be all one color save her face. And have you seen the Togruta (both the companion NPC and the new playable race)? Same deal, any face patterns don't extend to the rest of the body, it's lazy! The point is, in this instance I don't count SWTOR as a credible reference when the omission of a tail could have quite easily been lazy programming on an old game.

There's not a lot written about Cathar in Wookiepedia, and some image material from comics is shown, but I'm dubious on these. Okay, a few are shown clearly without tails, but they've also shown that there are sub-races with variations in the presentation of feline traits. What if there's a sub-race with tails? And I swear I remember mention of a Cathar who had a tail in one of the books, but I can't remember which book.

I know some GMs (just in general, can't speak for this game specifically since I'm still new) will make exceptions on some details, and while I am not necessarily asking for an exception, a little clarification of what is or is not acceptable for this is in order. I would like a tail for my Cathar character, but I certainly won't demand one. Just looking for a little friendly discussion and maybe some feedback from a moderator.
 

Sanya Val Lerium

Neutral, Queen of Her people, Neko
[member="Sha'do"] I could be entirely wrong but out of all the cathar characters I've seen don't have tails and even a lot of concept art don't display them, if yoy able to find the clone wars episode with them in I would take that as the canon answer.
 
Sha'do said:
I know some GMs (just in general, can't speak for this game specifically since I'm still new) will make exceptions on some details, and while I am not necessarily asking for an exception, a little clarification of what is or is not acceptable for this is in order. I would like a tail for my Cathar character, but I certainly won't demand one. Just looking for a little friendly discussion and maybe some feedback from a moderator.
Feel free to, if you'd like, in canon they do not normally have tails. Nobody is going to enforce this on you, as we don't really have GMs like you would have in more traditional board games like D&D
 

Sha'so

Looking for freedom...
[member="Lorelei Darke"] Loved your reply ^_^

Really, there were a lot of great replies in here, lots of things to think over. And [member="Sanya Val Lerium"] I will look for Cathar in the Clone Wars.


Valiens Nantaris said:
The short answer is that no, they don't seem to, but you could RP a subspecies which do if you'd like.
Would I have to write out details of the subspecies or just leave it assumed? Or can I just say "she has a tail" in her bio and leave it at that?
 
Valiens Nantaris said:
I pondered this very question yesterday.

The short answer is that no, they don't seem to, but you could RP a subspecies which do if you'd like.
Could also say "Cathar/Felecatian" and get a free "polymorph into a giant wildcat" card. :p

[member='Sha'do']
 
I don't think anyone is going to blow a whistle on you writing a Cathar with a tail.

Tails are of little consequence to anyone else, unless you're [member="Meeristali Peradun"] and getting it caught in things.
 
[member="Sha'do"] Tail functions are not very hard to program or animate in games. We did it in EQ and EQ2 with several races, including cat people.
 

Sha'so

Looking for freedom...
Arumi Zy said:
[member="Sha'do"] Tail functions are not very hard to program or animate in games. We did it in EQ and EQ2 with several races, including cat people.
Mmm, this is true. and even an old game like COH had animated tails before they were shut down, and that was an old, fairly broken platform. I'll modify my statement: SWTOR's dev team is understaffed and they cut a lot of corners. They've been telling people for years that a 'toggle hood' option is simply not possible, but we all know it's doable if they put their minds to it.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top Bottom