Extremely Interesting Theory on Rey

[Selena Halcyon]

Prophecies can also be failed.

One also can look at things another way. The prophecy was intended to see the end of the Sith. He ends the Sith when both himself and Sidious die. After all, this pulls from Obi-wan's understanding of the prophecy that Anakin was supposed to destroy the Sith not join them. This holds very nicely with the idea that balance in the force is the lightside, and that the darkside is corruption. To be balanced is in the light, so destroying the corruption (Sith) balances it.

Honestly, it is hard to argue that Luke actively did anything. He delivered no killing blow. He just was there as a tempting force for Vader to come back to the light. Little more. He was a beacon, but little more. Hard to really argue him fulfilling it, when Anakin still can be argued as fulfilling the prophecy despite his fall.

 

[Corey's OOC]

Ok. I'll bite.

Lets just say for a second that you're wrong. That felt good. But Luke baited everything.

If anything, Luke could be a catalyst for Vader's redemption, a redemption that destroyed the Sith, after Vader destroyed the Jedi.

Just, y'know, its a possibility.

 

[Selena Halcyon]

While a catalyst, that does not defer Chosen One status to him.

 

[Zaiden Dean]

Ok, but that's the point. Without Luke, the peace never would have happened. Vader would have likely crushed the rebellion, and they would have conquered the rest of the universe.

The darkside would have remained in power. Thus the real bringer of said peace, is Luke. Yes, Vader was the killer of Sidious, yes, Vader redeemed himself. But, in the end, Luke brought all of that possibility to be.

The end result is like I said, I believe Luke to be the One. Without him, there would be no peace.