nihil
Post here for just discussions in general.
Star Wars Roleplay: Chaos
Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!
Judge Discussion
- Thread starter Reverance
- Start date
Alkor Centaris
Son of Liberty
[member="Eralam"]
So, for round one, what say we split the judgments up between us? We can do the same for round two, and so forth. (You probably already had this idea, but I figured this'd put us on the same page.)
So, for round one, what say we split the judgments up between us? We can do the same for round two, and so forth. (You probably already had this idea, but I figured this'd put us on the same page.)
Eralam
Character
Yeah, got it in one. We split the judgments in half. And since we don't have enough to fill an 8 man bracket the next go, each of us picks out favorite loser as a wild card to move onto the next round.
[member="Alkor Centaris"]
[member="Alkor Centaris"]
Sinistra
Character
Since I'm not competing in the tournament, I'm free to judge as well.
Eralam
Character
That will help. I'll likely have limited access to the internet for most of May.
Sinistra
Character
I'm happy to tag in for you while you're out in the field.
Eralam
Character
Cool beans. I should have time to wrap up my judgments for the first round before heading out. I'll leave the second round to y'all.
Alkor Centaris
Son of Liberty
I'll handle the Adi/Admy judgment when it comes up so someone else can worry about Alky/Inky.
Son of Triam
Hey all, so I don't know how to judge others. I'm basically one of those yes men, who gives a thumbs up and a smile when someone asks me if something they did was good in real life, as I typically do not attach myself to any given situation to form a true opinion.
In fact, one of my core difficulties in life is forming an opinion when it involves people I know. Most often than not, I take the neutral road and support neither and both in equal portions. I attempt to mediate discussions, but never decide the "victor". So while I am aware that these references exist as a Duelist, trying to set myself into the mentality of a Judge and read them is impossible.
Could we perhaps make a guide for newbie Judges who need to be told what to look for specifically? It's one thing to understand how to take a measured hit, to decide when to be hit, and how to be generally respectful of your opponent when it's yourself, but applying that same logic when it's two strangers? I can't wrap my head around it.
Help please!
In fact, one of my core difficulties in life is forming an opinion when it involves people I know. Most often than not, I take the neutral road and support neither and both in equal portions. I attempt to mediate discussions, but never decide the "victor". So while I am aware that these references exist as a Duelist, trying to set myself into the mentality of a Judge and read them is impossible.
Could we perhaps make a guide for newbie Judges who need to be told what to look for specifically? It's one thing to understand how to take a measured hit, to decide when to be hit, and how to be generally respectful of your opponent when it's yourself, but applying that same logic when it's two strangers? I can't wrap my head around it.
Help please!
Eralam
Character
Yeah, I think I'm going to have to at some point. The old guide, while entertaining, assumes a certain amount of foreknowledge. Most everyone who applied for the position of judge had already been through at least a score of duels themselves and had a general idea of what they were looking at. That's just not the case here, and we don't have that foundation to build off of.
Eralam
Character
Anyone want the Mikhail vs Alky fight? Might be a little while before I can get to it.
Sinistra
Character
I can take it.Eralam said:
Eralam
Character
You're my hero.
Alkor Centaris
Son of Liberty
Thanks for handling that judgment, [member="Sinistra"] . It's very well done.
nihil
It was well done indeed
Alkor Centaris
Son of Liberty
[member="Eralam"], handled the judgment of the Adi/Aya fight.
When does the round end?
When does the round end?
Eralam
Character
Thanks for picking that up.
The threads should autolock tomorrow morning at 1000 EST. I just found out that my schedule for this week just went arse over teakettle, so how much I'll be around is anyone's guess. And starting tomorrow evening, I'll be gone for a few weeks.
The threads should autolock tomorrow morning at 1000 EST. I just found out that my schedule for this week just went arse over teakettle, so how much I'll be around is anyone's guess. And starting tomorrow evening, I'll be gone for a few weeks.
Alkor Centaris
Son of Liberty
We'll handle shit on this end while you're gone.
Take care and such, and may the booze be with you mate.
Take care and such, and may the booze be with you mate.
Eralam
Character
All the matches are locked and ready for judgment. I'll try to grab one before the day's festivities kick off.
