Directorate Officer
"What I would like to do is make a copy of your programming, and place it in another droid chassis that it would temporarily inhabit. That copy of you could then observe and oversee the whole process. If we did not do that, you would be able to delete everything in that programming that we are interested in studying."
"You are suggesting that I can use a form of suicide to keep you in check. You do understand how that could be perceived as distasteful..."
"From a certain point of view, yes, it could be considered that. We're going out on a limb though that you won't simply delete it once we have fulfilled our end of the bargain."
"But even if that was the case, you could come back in force to try and take it back."
"Yes, that is true," admitted Gir, "and during that time, you could fortify this place and prepare it to resist; quite possibly to the point where it would cost more to both of us than it would actually be worth."
"So it comes down to question of do I trust that you will be rational enough to not escalate a situation. You see the problem with that argument?"
"It's not a perfect solution, I'll admit, but what are the other options that we can consider?"
"I could ask you to simply leave."
"You could, but there's no guarantee that either myself or one of my associates wouldn't come back later, in force, as you said if we are really determined to study your existence. Or alternatively, we could tell other people about your existence here."
"I dislike any attempt at blackmail," said the droid, "but it is clear that even if I were to kill you now, more of you would come. What guarantee can you give me that you, or others like you, will not come back?"
"You are suggesting that I can use a form of suicide to keep you in check. You do understand how that could be perceived as distasteful..."
"From a certain point of view, yes, it could be considered that. We're going out on a limb though that you won't simply delete it once we have fulfilled our end of the bargain."
"But even if that was the case, you could come back in force to try and take it back."
"Yes, that is true," admitted Gir, "and during that time, you could fortify this place and prepare it to resist; quite possibly to the point where it would cost more to both of us than it would actually be worth."
"So it comes down to question of do I trust that you will be rational enough to not escalate a situation. You see the problem with that argument?"
"It's not a perfect solution, I'll admit, but what are the other options that we can consider?"
"I could ask you to simply leave."
"You could, but there's no guarantee that either myself or one of my associates wouldn't come back later, in force, as you said if we are really determined to study your existence. Or alternatively, we could tell other people about your existence here."
"I dislike any attempt at blackmail," said the droid, "but it is clear that even if I were to kill you now, more of you would come. What guarantee can you give me that you, or others like you, will not come back?"