I literally read the first Twilight book so that when I told people I hated it, I could say I'd read it. One thing I loathe is when people assume I don't try something before I hate it.
Regardless, my review is as such;
The book does a horrendous amount of things wrong, and the writing is iffy at best. BUT, it nailed down the demographic it wanted and became popular because of that, so it clearly did something right in the eyes of said demographic.
Nevermind that the relationship is creepy in the extreme but that's something else entirely.