Sarge Potteiger
Emotional Damage
[member="Loske Matson"] [member="Cira"]
A hand came up, brushing at his jaw, and then his index finger and his thumb slipped between his lips. Whistling in a piercing manner, he looked to her with a concerned furrow to his weathered brow, thumb brushing at the right corner of his mouth in apparent study of her eyes. "If you think you did, you probably did." He begins carefully, voice neutral. This was a subject broached with caution, if only because it was clear the memory of such a thing was still fresh in her mind.
"The sum of a decision lay within the outcome, but it also lay within the process in which it was made as well as perspective.
Say, for example, you and I are manning the line somewhere, and the enemy pushes into a neighboring sector. I comm for permission for you to take your men and flank them, and command tells me no. I send you anyway, and we find out later that if we hadn't done that the line wouldn't have held.
That is a correct decision, but it is also the wrong decision. I have been insubordinate, but I have saved lives. It's a cost benefit analysis. Staying in place would have been the wrong-right decision, which sounds silly, but it's true.
'Correct' decisions rarely come in black and white, and much like the truth, you find that they live in a world of gray." As he spoke, his hands gesticulated in a reserved manner, his hands half flexing as if gripping a large ball of nothing. As he said black and white, they gestured left and right, before going palm outward when he said 'gray.' It seemed to keep him on track. "But let's operate on the assumption that this was the wrong decision to make.
Did you accomplish enough to make it a good one?"
A hand came up, brushing at his jaw, and then his index finger and his thumb slipped between his lips. Whistling in a piercing manner, he looked to her with a concerned furrow to his weathered brow, thumb brushing at the right corner of his mouth in apparent study of her eyes. "If you think you did, you probably did." He begins carefully, voice neutral. This was a subject broached with caution, if only because it was clear the memory of such a thing was still fresh in her mind.
"The sum of a decision lay within the outcome, but it also lay within the process in which it was made as well as perspective.
Say, for example, you and I are manning the line somewhere, and the enemy pushes into a neighboring sector. I comm for permission for you to take your men and flank them, and command tells me no. I send you anyway, and we find out later that if we hadn't done that the line wouldn't have held.
That is a correct decision, but it is also the wrong decision. I have been insubordinate, but I have saved lives. It's a cost benefit analysis. Staying in place would have been the wrong-right decision, which sounds silly, but it's true.
'Correct' decisions rarely come in black and white, and much like the truth, you find that they live in a world of gray." As he spoke, his hands gesticulated in a reserved manner, his hands half flexing as if gripping a large ball of nothing. As he said black and white, they gestured left and right, before going palm outward when he said 'gray.' It seemed to keep him on track. "But let's operate on the assumption that this was the wrong decision to make.
Did you accomplish enough to make it a good one?"