Eternal Father
She might be.
Star Wars Roleplay: Chaos
Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!
TFA Question
- Thread starter Valiens Nantaris
- Start date
-
- Tags
- spoilers
The Forgotten One
[member="Valiens Nantaris"]. You know when Kylo spoke of her past, he mentions an island in an ocean. Which the final place she visits in the movies is an ocean planet on a small island. When
Interesting fact about her vision at Maz's place, if you listen carefully you can hear Obi-Wan.
Interesting fact about her vision at Maz's place, if you listen carefully you can hear Obi-Wan.
Selena Halcyon
Jedi Master
The answer is no.
She is definitely not his daughter. Here are a few of significant issues.
1) She's left on Jakku with the junk dealer. Not with the guy who is a part of the Church of the Force at the beginning. If she'd been left with him then it'd make sense, however, she's left with a scumbag which Luke would never do.
2) Luke would not get married or have kids. Luke's got the weight of the Jedi order on his back. He's also going to try and honor their legacy.
3) The timeline doesn't make sense. The only point which Luke would leave her would be after Kylo did his thing. Rey is ~20 and Kylo is at most 30. So if Rey is left at 5 as we are led to believe that would mean, at most Kylo was 15 when he destroyed the Order. That makes zero sense.
4) Kylo never speaks of her past. He doesn't know who she is. At most he is aware that she is the one which the force has awakened in. I get into his reactions relating to her here.
5) The lightsaber calling to her does not necessitate familial ties. It merely indicates which side of the Force she is intended to be on. One thing to keep in mind is that in Star Wars movies the will of the Force is super important and moves things. Personal agency is only secondary to the Will of the Force which consistently sets up crazy circumstances. It needs her to be trained, getting Luke's saber would set her on that past.
6) Maz clearly says that her family is never coming back. The implication is that they're gone and not worth waiting for. What she looks for is implicitly a place and a family, but that does not have to be genetic. Instead what she seeks, love and belonging, is in the future with her destiny. Maz isn't saying Luke is her father.
extra) people say the movie has to have a Skywalker. It does. In Kylo.
She is definitely not his daughter. Here are a few of significant issues.
1) She's left on Jakku with the junk dealer. Not with the guy who is a part of the Church of the Force at the beginning. If she'd been left with him then it'd make sense, however, she's left with a scumbag which Luke would never do.
2) Luke would not get married or have kids. Luke's got the weight of the Jedi order on his back. He's also going to try and honor their legacy.
3) The timeline doesn't make sense. The only point which Luke would leave her would be after Kylo did his thing. Rey is ~20 and Kylo is at most 30. So if Rey is left at 5 as we are led to believe that would mean, at most Kylo was 15 when he destroyed the Order. That makes zero sense.
4) Kylo never speaks of her past. He doesn't know who she is. At most he is aware that she is the one which the force has awakened in. I get into his reactions relating to her here.
5) The lightsaber calling to her does not necessitate familial ties. It merely indicates which side of the Force she is intended to be on. One thing to keep in mind is that in Star Wars movies the will of the Force is super important and moves things. Personal agency is only secondary to the Will of the Force which consistently sets up crazy circumstances. It needs her to be trained, getting Luke's saber would set her on that past.
6) Maz clearly says that her family is never coming back. The implication is that they're gone and not worth waiting for. What she looks for is implicitly a place and a family, but that does not have to be genetic. Instead what she seeks, love and belonging, is in the future with her destiny. Maz isn't saying Luke is her father.
extra) people say the movie has to have a Skywalker. It does. In Kylo.
Jsc
Disney's Princess
QFT.Selena Halcyon said:
The Skywalker Legacy is definitely found in the first three movies. Luke redeeming his father from the dark. Kylo figures that following Vader is where he fits in this Legacy. That's the Skywalker in him.
I really look forward to a confrontation between Kylo and Luke. That to me is where the real Skywalker Destiny Showdown will take it's course. Listen as Luke describes one fate of the galaxy while Kylo demands another. Both Skywalker. Both equally able to command the Force and the future along it's river course.
Yet Rey.
Mmm. Fascinating.
Eternal Father
I wanna see a trained Rey go against a further trained Kylo
Valiens Nantaris
Head Admin
Next movie I dare say you will.Darth Vornskr said:I wanna see a trained Rey go against a further trained Kylo
Thanks for the replies, novelisation hmm? Might check that out.