Tiland steepled his fingers as he considered everything the others had said, interlacing and unlacing them in contemplation before running his fingers through his beard. The situation was complex and he half-closed his eyes to run through the list of things. If this was a trial, what were the crimes. These he listed in his head.
Crime One: Turning to the Dark Side. Did she choose to turn to the Dark Side? By all indications, no. And with Romi's added testimony, there was a strong chance it was something she was unaware of, and thus, had no knowledge of the possibility and thus could not be prepared for whatever had happened to make it happen. Especially with the words that the Sith was kind and came telling her she wasn't who she thought she was and offered to help her when she was scared. By that assessment, his verdict was not guilty.
Crime Two: Self-confessing to the murder of a corrupt Alliance Senator. Fact- she did kill the man via stabbing with a knife. Was that, however, murder? His mind parsed through the variety of different meanings and intentions. But what it all came down to was that this was in the context of a combat mission. An illegal, off-the-books combat mission, yes, but still a combat mission, and not in a premeditated manner either, but one in which someone she cared about was under direct, immediate threat. By all rules of engagement, he was aware of, that was acceptable. An ideal method for Jedi? No, of course not, but she was also not fully a Jedi yet. The accusation of murder- not guilty.
Crime Three: Stabbing Thridas Heavenshield. Fact, she did stab him while under the control of the Sith. As far as he was concerned, that verdict was not his to judge, but up to Thirdas.
Crime Four, Implied: Aiding and abetting the enemy in a time of war. In that, even though it was against her full consciousness, that was something that had been done and was the primary charge being addressed.
He considered the terms suggest by Master Quill, who also had a point. The Jedi had gained a reputation over the past few decades of sweeping problems under the rug in the name of forgiveness. There were real victims of what the young Nida had performed or been part of, even unwillingly.
Tiland cleared his throat after a moment. "When it comes to the situations at hand, I see four charges being assessed and intermixed. One, joining the Sith, which is not technically referenced anywhere in the Jedi Code, and therefore cannot be a violation. Furthermore, given the circumstances and context, I see no evidence to suggest that it was a willing choice or even one that she was consciously aware of. Rather, it seems to have been forced upon her in a way that could not have at the time been anticipated, defended against, or protected against. This, I see not as a crime to be punished, but as a trauma derived from a loss of agency to be worked through by the defendant as a process of healing and awareness growth.
Charge two- the self-confessed murder of an Alliance Senator. The fact is that she did indeed kill the man. However-" He paused to acknowledge the irony of the situation. "It was in the context of a combat mission in which the man was armed and threatening a comrade in arms. By all rules of engagement I am aware of, that is not murder, but necessary action. The state of mind and motivation in which the action occurred are
not Jedi-like, but are natural experiences in a time of war. My assessment is that of the murder charge, the defendant is not guilty. Unfortunately, there are the political implications of the event, which is very complicated and one I am neither qualified for nor capable of passing judgment upon. I also recognize that the admittance of murder suggests deep remorse and a genuine desire to atone for the act, which the defendant considered to be morally wrong. For judgment such as this, only the defendant will know when justice has been accomplished, in the same way, that many of the man's victims undoubtedly consider his death to be justice. What is justice when injustice is perpetrated by those with the power to influence a society's laws and views on what justice means?" He shrugged. "I do not know."
He considered for a moment. "Charge Three- the assault and stabbing of Thirdas Heavenshield, who appears to be within this audience. As this appears to be primarily a personal matter, I will defer judgment to the victim for what justice looks like in this situation." A moment of consideration again before he spoke.
"The fourth and final primary charge I can discern is one that has not been publically addressed- aiding and abetting the enemy during a time of war. Actions committed by the Sith during which the defendant was seen to have been acting on their behalf have real victims, regardless of whether or not the defendant was knowingly assisting. Those victims too deserve justice. As to what this justice looks like, I am not sure I can rightfully judge."
With that, he leaned forward and nodded towards Jend-Ro. "I am more than willing to take on the defendant in this process, although I think exile is less of the right word than convalescence might be, as well as threat assessment. Sith Poison, genetic trigger, I do not know, but my concern for the future is this- the prevention of the Sith again taking advantage whatever they have to control the defendant, maintaining and restoring trust in the Jedi amongst the broader community, and finally, but not least, the process of healing and coming to terms with what happened the defendant will have to engage in. For these, I think accountability, supervision, and public service will be of far greater value of restoring justice within the broader community and some form of counseling and medical treatment necessary for restoring the sense of justice within the defendant, and will, ultimately, come down to the defendant's own sense of what justice requires, as she has already freely confessed to things that many of us do not seem to consider crimes." His eyes twinkled for a moment. "Though I do see a pattern of misplaced trust in older, more experienced individuals and a lack of sound judgment that seems to have led to the most egregious incident with the Senator. That, however, speaks more to us and our own inability or unwillingness to keep our peers accountable to their own actions. For this, I ask the defendant's forgiveness for my own actions or inactions that allowed such things to occur. The inexperience of youth is not something that we should be allowing to be exploited, and worse, failing to consider."
Thirdas Heavenshield
Jend-Ro Quill
Zark San Tekka
Romi Jade
Coren Starchaser
Celeste Rigel
Nida Perl
Thurion Heavenshield
@everyone else