Writer Feedback

[Rusken Shaxx]

Seems like a solid idea!

 

[Fatty]

I would approve, though perhaps the "Feedback" should be "Criticisms" so that way we can stay clear of a public praise party, though of course that doesn't stop anyone from PMing you praise

 

[Fatty]

And perhaps a small little template to keep such crticisms constructive, and stay clear of roasting territory

 

[Darth Ferus]

[member="Fatty"]

I'll write up a template after work then.

 

[Ilias Nytrau]

I'm not here for the cookies (thanks, though), but I can tell you that I've seen people request feedback on their characters in an earnest attempt to improve their writing on other forums and it's gone over rather well. I agree with [member="Reverance"] here:

I approve of the idea, so long as people can accept the possibility of true tough love constructive criticism.

And I agree with [member="Fatty"], but by and large I think most people would see 'criticism' as negative. 'Writing Feedback', 'Character Feedback', 'Critiques' would accomplish the same, with less of the negativity.

So I'm all for it, I'd love to see how this goes.

 

[Tefka]

You mean the one ive insulted Tef in for the multiple times hes done thing

#sobrave

 

[Alexandra Feanor]

[member="Tefka"]

Hey, i don't like your personality or how you run things in some aspects, i wont lie. Especially when you do shit like back when that guy made another site and you pretty much gave every bit of personal information on the guy so that we could as a board haze and insult him. NOt to mention numerous faction related incidents and just when i talk to you ooc. Im sorry but thats the truthm i don't like how you act as an admin and don't trust you. Thus why i go to Thurion or Maria with anything needing an RPJ or Admin.

 

[Jsc]

#sobrave

Love ya Tef'ers. May you get the respect you deserve in League Chat.

*snickers*

I mean Staff Chat.

*snickers*

I mean, I hope you have friends in Real Life. Cause this place is a handful.

 

[Jorus Merrill]

I've got an idea! Let's hijack threads discussing mutual benefit and trust so we can bring up irrelevant personal grievances ad nauseum!

Or not.


On a more serious note, I'm interested to see what form this takes.

 

[Jsc]

I've got an idea! Let's hijack threads discussing mutual benefit and trust so we can bring up irrelevant personal grievances ad nauseum!

Feedback for Jorus: God I love you. Haha. *hits dat LIKE button*

 

[Tefka]

[member="Alexandra Lianne Feanor"]

Who are you, lol

I'm going to go with Jorus on this one, I don't actually care. Submit your feedback about your dislike of me via a different thread if you feel like it, but I'm banning you from this one.

 

[Anija Betna]

I request people to keep their personal issues with staff out of this thread, as that is NOT it's intent. On a thread related note, I'm all for this, echoing [member="Reverance"]'s caveat.

 

[Minna]

I support this

 

[Edward Vyperion]

*to the tune of the treasure get theme from Zelda* Da da da daaaaa! I approve

 

[Edric Vanyan]

[member="Tefka"]

Hey man, did this get enough people? Im curious to know if so because this should till be a thing if possible. It would help people fix some stuff about their writing abilities as well as tell them why people like or dislike certain characters. It would also provide people with an output on anything they do wrong or particularly break lore or power wise and help keep staff from getting stuff about powergaming... though im not sure how often it is that you get such, so ya.

 

[Ellie Mors]

I'd like to see this happen as well.

 

[Vrag]

I second this

 

[Mrrew]

I love this idea.

 

[Julius Sedaire]

I'd like to see it happen, but I doubt people will do the critiques. I sincerely think they will become praise party type threads. Or the few genuine critiques will be met with whining and gnashing of teeth. But go ahead and try it, it'd be interesting.

 

[Rianna Organa]

This sounds good to me, I usually talk about my writing skills with the people I'm writing with but perhaps someone who is not familiar with my writing would have some constructive criticisms.