For Honor
Star Wars Roleplay: Chaos
Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!
Second Chance Till Dec 2019
- Thread starter Srina Talon
- Start date
-
- Tags
- codex
- Status
S H A D O W
[member="Lisza Starseeker"] Done.
M E A T B A G
[member="Allyson Locke"] | [member="Irajah Ven"] | [member="Zeradias Mant"] - Whenever you have a chance, could I ask that this submission be removed from the archives and placed back in the Pre-Codex section? Thank you. 
Two-Bit Con Artist
[member="Khonsu Amon"]
Done
Done
Velok the Younger
When I Was A Young Warthog
[member="Allyson Locke"]
This got archived while I was moving: http://starwarsrp.net/topic/135225-the-toglannoq-we-who-walk-the-ice/
The weapon in question was commissioned for the Whiphids, as explained in its description, by Velok.
This got archived while I was moving: http://starwarsrp.net/topic/135225-the-toglannoq-we-who-walk-the-ice/
The weapon in question was commissioned for the Whiphids, as explained in its description, by Velok.
Prazutis
Prudii Kyr'am Alor/Mandalorian Elder
[member="Allyson Locke"]
I wish for a different judge on this submission please.
http://starwarsrp.net/topic/135780-the-otadaye/
I have already given everything he's asking for and I'm not willing to lower security standards on it
I wish for a different judge on this submission please.
http://starwarsrp.net/topic/135780-the-otadaye/
I have already given everything he's asking for and I'm not willing to lower security standards on it
S H A D O W
All handled...yes.
Vespasian the Elder
Lord Executor
[member="Allyson Locke"]
http://starwarsrp.net/topic/137789-ignatum-and-invicta-mantellian-commonwealth/#entry1880727
I am requesting this to be reviewed.
I personally see no sense, maybe due to lacking explanation, why to remove a crucial detail from the submission.
Everywhere else I note the encouragement to expand on details and the necessarity to give them, but not here?
We shall give squadron counts, lengths of ships, character heights or ages but not manpower? That sounds rather nonsensical.
So I request to either explain it to me in a logical way which makes sense or to simply re-judge the submission.
http://starwarsrp.net/topic/137789-ignatum-and-invicta-mantellian-commonwealth/#entry1880727
I am requesting this to be reviewed.
I personally see no sense, maybe due to lacking explanation, why to remove a crucial detail from the submission.
Everywhere else I note the encouragement to expand on details and the necessarity to give them, but not here?
We shall give squadron counts, lengths of ships, character heights or ages but not manpower? That sounds rather nonsensical.
So I request to either explain it to me in a logical way which makes sense or to simply re-judge the submission.
S H A D O W
Its not a critical detail necessary for the submission. If you want hard numbers then you should keep them in your notes. RP doesnt function on hard numbers and only provides confusion to other writers.
After reviewing your submission, you were very hard pressed to not change when the judge provided an explanation for you. You were unwilling to be open minded. A judge is there to help you bring your submission to the standards of the board at large.
Also ship length are needed for fleet sizes, character age and height are descriptors but you dont have to put it. Your judge explained it, but it seemed you didn't want to accept it.
The hard number should and needs to be removed to keep it in line with other submissions and the template. You're more than welcomed to keep the number in your notes and present them when rp happens, but do not readily expect your opponent or another writer to be so ready with hard numbers, since we do not function with hard numbers.
[member="Vespasian the Elder"]
After reviewing your submission, you were very hard pressed to not change when the judge provided an explanation for you. You were unwilling to be open minded. A judge is there to help you bring your submission to the standards of the board at large.
Also ship length are needed for fleet sizes, character age and height are descriptors but you dont have to put it. Your judge explained it, but it seemed you didn't want to accept it.
The hard number should and needs to be removed to keep it in line with other submissions and the template. You're more than welcomed to keep the number in your notes and present them when rp happens, but do not readily expect your opponent or another writer to be so ready with hard numbers, since we do not function with hard numbers.
[member="Vespasian the Elder"]
Vespasian the Elder
Lord Executor
[member="Allyson Locke"]
Feth.
As you say. Open it again and I will remove the number ...
Feth.
As you say. Open it again and I will remove the number ...
Prazutis
Prudii Kyr'am Alor/Mandalorian Elder
http://starwarsrp.net/topic/140832-dxun-canon-planet/#entry1909407
I'd like a second chance at this with a different judge that is more helpful as my current one gave no help, crowd resourcing is not helping
I'd like a second chance at this with a different judge that is more helpful as my current one gave no help, crowd resourcing is not helping
Two-Bit Con Artist
@A'den Kyr'am
As per our PM, I'll be archiving this sub at your request.
As per our PM, I'll be archiving this sub at your request.
- Status