Star Wars Roleplay: Chaos
Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!
Ren Tags.
- Thread starter Darth Ferus
- Start date
-
- Tags
- suggestion
Aspiring Jedi
[member="Jay Scott Clark"]
That probably is the best way to go. The site shall speak like the Republic, and the Admins will come forth and Sith you all.
That probably is the best way to go. The site shall speak like the Republic, and the Admins will come forth and Sith you all.
skin, bone, and arrogance
You know I love you, but this is really stupidJay Scott Clark said:
"Gaming" rank tags? "leveraging the majority"? Neither of these allegations really make sense. I mean, we're not talking about a tactical advantage or putting upon anyone else. It impacts literally nothing. No member of 'the majority' will be impacted in any way. Adding three additional tags may cause milliseconds of additional scrolling for the staff when assigning new ranks, but it will take years for that to add up to minutes of additional time. If your argument is "I just don't want them to have it" say so, because at least we'll know what we're dealing with -- and it really does just sound like that.
Darth Ferus
Wanderer
[member="Jay Scott Clark"]
Will do!
... once i figure out how to on my phone.
Will do!
... once i figure out how to on my phone.
Darth Ferus
Wanderer
Not as hard as I thought.
Polls up! Let your voices be heard through a simple button click.
Polls up! Let your voices be heard through a simple button click.
Delicate
If I am not mistaken, this has already been raised in the past and was shot down by the admins during the last tags update. I forget the specifics, but I was pretty certain that it was denied.
Zeradias Mant
Democracy Dies in Darkness
I have and will continue to be against the use of Ren tags. So long as they apply to a single faction, it will remain a niche. Other factions don't need exclusive FU tags for their faction, and the First Order is no different. This is definitely one of those situations where it's 'if I say yes to you, then I have to say yes to everyone'. As far as the witches go, while the Witches of Dathomir may have been the original intent, they do have a broader applicability with a more primitive style of Force users.
Don't get me wrong, I get why you guys want them, but I still fail to see why you need them or why their addition would be better for Chaos as a whole.
Don't get me wrong, I get why you guys want them, but I still fail to see why you need them or why their addition would be better for Chaos as a whole.
[member="Darth Ferox"] It's canon, so it exists, and as you say it'll get bigger and grow with the new episodes.
The First Order managed to rise from 'TFA' here, so let's inject another new "resurrection" of the Knights of Ren for new and old fans coming here to explore.
The First Order managed to rise from 'TFA' here, so let's inject another new "resurrection" of the Knights of Ren for new and old fans coming here to explore.
Laira Darkhold
Well-Known Member
Last time it was asked, this was said in regards to the Ren receiving Rank Tags.
This is the current list of Ren from the FO Faction Tracker.
And this thread is it not being a Rank Tag Competition.Rolf Amsel said:
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------[member="Wolf"][member="Samka Derith"][member="Isla Ashen"][member="Anor Ren"][member="Kriel Firin"][member="Greifen Ren"]
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------[member="Castor Ren"][member="Phenex Ren"][member="Viktor DuSang"][member="Misha Ren"][member="Thresh Sken"][member="Perth Levov"][member="Soleil Ishtar"][member="Darren Onyx"][member="Morrison Jericho"]
Darth Ferus
Wanderer
[member="Zeradias Mant"]
The way I see it, nine out of ten people who come here now will know of the Ren. I dunno how many people of those will want to be a Ren, but with the ren tags under the name will give those who want to be ren the ability to easily identify who is and PM them.
Sure its in the sig, but if you're lile me you only read those if you're waiting for a post and are too lazy to pop on youtube for videos.
The way I see it, nine out of ten people who come here now will know of the Ren. I dunno how many people of those will want to be a Ren, but with the ren tags under the name will give those who want to be ren the ability to easily identify who is and PM them.
Sure its in the sig, but if you're lile me you only read those if you're waiting for a post and are too lazy to pop on youtube for videos.
Zeradias Mant
Democracy Dies in Darkness
[member="Darth Ferox"]
Know of Kylo Ren maybe, but the Knights of Ren wiki page is hardly two paragraphs and are far lesser known than you would think. If you're referencing the First Order's Force user order, they're probably a little more known on Chaos, but still, adding their tag does not contribute to Chaos for the better. I'm pretty sure ease of recruitment and access to information for prospects for a single faction doesn't constitute a valid justification for their addition either.
Know of Kylo Ren maybe, but the Knights of Ren wiki page is hardly two paragraphs and are far lesser known than you would think. If you're referencing the First Order's Force user order, they're probably a little more known on Chaos, but still, adding their tag does not contribute to Chaos for the better. I'm pretty sure ease of recruitment and access to information for prospects for a single faction doesn't constitute a valid justification for their addition either.
Darth Ferus
Wanderer
[member="Zeradias Mant"]
You are correct in that regard!
But! Another thought. The Jedi were made in cannon to serve the Republic. There was no multi group syndrome ( at least in Disney cannon).
Same with the Sith (again, disney).
Who's to say that when the movies come out there wont be multiple Ren groups running around? Sure, its an unknown and thus shouodnt be a thing now.
But why not make it a thing now?
[member="Draco Vereen"]
I didnt know of that thread or anything asked in it. Thanks for bringing attention to it! I suppose it means this vote is somewhat useless now.
But, I'll keep it up and going just to see how many on the site want it. Who knows, if enough people do it'll be a thing anyway.
You are correct in that regard!
But! Another thought. The Jedi were made in cannon to serve the Republic. There was no multi group syndrome ( at least in Disney cannon).
Same with the Sith (again, disney).
Who's to say that when the movies come out there wont be multiple Ren groups running around? Sure, its an unknown and thus shouodnt be a thing now.
But why not make it a thing now?
[member="Draco Vereen"]
I didnt know of that thread or anything asked in it. Thanks for bringing attention to it! I suppose it means this vote is somewhat useless now.
But, I'll keep it up and going just to see how many on the site want it. Who knows, if enough people do it'll be a thing anyway.
Zeradias Mant
Democracy Dies in Darkness
[member="Darth Ferox"]
The Jedi Order predates the formation of the Galactic Republic, and they originally distanced themselves from it purposefully. Rather than type up a storm here though, I'll leave you with a link to the wiki for the Jedi Order so you can read up on it if you so choose. I'd be lying if I said I was an expert on the topic, but it does make for a good read, even if only in bits and pieces. Compare even just the length of it with the Knights of Ren wiki, and it's a bit easier to see why there's multiple Jedi orders on Chaos.
Nonetheless though, this isn't so much about the canon Knights of Ren so much as it is the Chaos Knights of Ren. Everything I've said before though previously still stands and applies just as well.
The Jedi Order predates the formation of the Galactic Republic, and they originally distanced themselves from it purposefully. Rather than type up a storm here though, I'll leave you with a link to the wiki for the Jedi Order so you can read up on it if you so choose. I'd be lying if I said I was an expert on the topic, but it does make for a good read, even if only in bits and pieces. Compare even just the length of it with the Knights of Ren wiki, and it's a bit easier to see why there's multiple Jedi orders on Chaos.
Pretty sure there won't be. It is an unknown, but that's more of a reason not to make it a thing.
Nonetheless though, this isn't so much about the canon Knights of Ren so much as it is the Chaos Knights of Ren. Everything I've said before though previously still stands and applies just as well.
Edric Vanyan
The Historian King
Honestly, the Knights of Ren are just an order of Dark Jedi... so no
skin, bone, and arrogance
Which presumably forbids any further discussion?Jamie Pyne said:
For the record the last time it was brought up the conclusion was that the Ren had not shown a staying power as yet. Not that it would and could never be, just that the timing was not right.
Unless staff policy has changed and no one bothered to tell us (which is highly unlikely though possible), perhaps it would be wise to avoid discouraging a discussion of the merits.
skin, bone, and arrogance
According to JJ Abrams, you are wrong. But he just created the concept, so what does he know?Edric Vanyan said:
Edric Vanyan
The Historian King
[member="Natasi Fortan"]
Ok, do tell me how they are different from Dark Jedi?
Ok, do tell me how they are different from Dark Jedi?
Delicate
Pretty sure that is not even remotely close to what I said, so please don't put words in my mouth.Natasi Fortan said:
I simply stated what the last result of said discussion was for those who may not have been present for it.
Darth Ferus
Wanderer
[member="Jamie Pyne"]
Abraham lincoln ran for president.. i dunno how many times, and eventually won.
If there's a will, theres a way.
[member="Natasi Fortan"]
It is good to know what was said last time, and it is important to recognize what was saiid last and see if its been adressed.
But lets keep this civil. Everyone has opinions and shouldn't be damned for them. (Unless you're a heathenis Jedi scum of course)
Abraham lincoln ran for president.. i dunno how many times, and eventually won.
If there's a will, theres a way.
[member="Natasi Fortan"]
It is good to know what was said last time, and it is important to recognize what was saiid last and see if its been adressed.
But lets keep this civil. Everyone has opinions and shouldn't be damned for them. (Unless you're a heathenis Jedi scum of course
)