Kamon's OOC
Well-Known Member
[member="Darth Vornskr"]
But he can ask him not to join.
But he can ask him not to join.
Star Wars Roleplay: Chaos
Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!
Eternal Father
True, True.
[member="Barrien Siegfried"]
I was just saying that when it boiled down to it he can't exactly prevent him from doing it.
Even if it'd be seen as rude.
[member="Barrien Siegfried"]
I was just saying that when it boiled down to it he can't exactly prevent him from doing it.
Even if it'd be seen as rude.
Kamon's OOC
Well-Known Member
[member="Darth Vornskr"]
Right. But he was asking him not to.
It's a matter of being polite, really. Like right now, I wouldn't anyone to interfere with my fight with Bix. It would ruin the story we're telling.
Right. But he was asking him not to.
It's a matter of being polite, really. Like right now, I wouldn't anyone to interfere with my fight with Bix. It would ruin the story we're telling.
Garith Darkhold
Dark Kashi
I just wanted to give a shout out to [member="Barrien Siegfried"] and to SWRP Chaos. It has been a long time since I’ve enjoyed a duel or invasion. Thank you Barrrien for the duel and thank you Chaos for having a decent system in place where writers can enjoy their stories. 
Kamon's OOC
Well-Known Member
[member="Bix Slisia"]
It's nice to have a duel be about story. It was a good one. You're welcome, and thank you as well.
It's nice to have a duel be about story. It was a good one. You're welcome, and thank you as well.
Kira Talith
Kinetic Communication at its finest my Chick-e-dee
[member="Darth Ophidia"]
Zap zap floozy! And your Najajj too!
Zap zap floozy! And your Najajj too!
Nerius
Iron Knight
[member="Ella Nova"] [member="Mullarus"]
With the invasion drawing to a close, I hope we can come up with something soon. I do not mind calling it a draw, but I always find decisive battles more alluring. Either or though, has been enjoyable, and interesting!
PS. Totes gonna knark on you Mullarus!!
With the invasion drawing to a close, I hope we can come up with something soon. I do not mind calling it a draw, but I always find decisive battles more alluring. Either or though, has been enjoyable, and interesting!
PS. Totes gonna knark on you Mullarus!!
Mantic Dorn
Old school...
Now I am getting mixed signals. If above is true, the invasions rule are in a terrible poor shape. I could simply find acolytes and force myself on them for 90% certain wins. The idea is always to find a match, unless one self is challanged by a lower tier.Darth Vornskr said:
Also without any ooc contact previous to battle he just leaped into the fight saving [member="Agamemnon"] and agamemnon has already posted his reply. I feel tricked and made a fool of.
[member="Darth Carach"] - I do not want to write you (can it be clearer). Come out and make an ooc response please.
please remove your post and [member="Agamemnon"] edit yours accordingly. I have ovelooked late posting with you before (when you forgot our fight) and I can do it again to sort this mess.
[member="Corvus Raaf"] [member="Reverance"] [member="Vrag"] [member="Geneviève Lasedri"]
Jairus Starvald
Eidoloclast
[member="Mantic Dorn"] [member="Agamemnon"]
I was sleeping. Just like you had your party, I also had things to do outside the board.
Anyway, I am kinda done with this attitude. This is an invasion. An invasion is an open thread to both parties, where people can engage one another - if you want to lock yourself down in a private realm where nobody else can touch you, create a duel thread or a private thread.
Two times now I got told there was a fight I could join by my admins, and yet again I am being fed the same old story.
So as far as I am concerned my post still stands, but it isn't my job to decide what goes and doesn't go in this invasion, that's on the FAs. So let them make the decision.
I was sleeping. Just like you had your party, I also had things to do outside the board.
Anyway, I am kinda done with this attitude. This is an invasion. An invasion is an open thread to both parties, where people can engage one another - if you want to lock yourself down in a private realm where nobody else can touch you, create a duel thread or a private thread.
Two times now I got told there was a fight I could join by my admins, and yet again I am being fed the same old story.
So as far as I am concerned my post still stands, but it isn't my job to decide what goes and doesn't go in this invasion, that's on the FAs. So let them make the decision.
Eternal Father
I remember when Dooku forbade Yoda from intervening in the duel at the end of Attack of the Clones because he didn't want him to join.
[member="Darth Carach"]
[member="Darth Carach"]
Mantic Dorn
Old school...
[member="Darth Carach"]
[member="Agamemnon"]
Alright, I think I have made my point clear. I do not want to write with you in this invasion, but yes - since we dont agree and you obviously want to write with me I think we reached a point where it is up to FAs.
Mean while I suggest we put a pause on the posting. Can we agree to that?
So a word from FAs would be nice.
[member="Corvus Raaf"] [member="Vrag"] [member="Reverance"] [member="Geneviève Lasedri"]
[member="Agamemnon"]
Alright, I think I have made my point clear. I do not want to write with you in this invasion, but yes - since we dont agree and you obviously want to write with me I think we reached a point where it is up to FAs.
Mean while I suggest we put a pause on the posting. Can we agree to that?
So a word from FAs would be nice.
[member="Corvus Raaf"] [member="Vrag"] [member="Reverance"] [member="Geneviève Lasedri"]
Corvus Raaf
Adieu...
[member="Mantic Dorn"]
I remember seeing a post from Reverance in which it was made very, very clear you do NOT simply join an existing duel without permission.
Not aware that stance has changed.
[member="Taeli Raaf"] - [member="Reverance"]
I remember seeing a post from Reverance in which it was made very, very clear you do NOT simply join an existing duel without permission.
Not aware that stance has changed.
[member="Taeli Raaf"] - [member="Reverance"]
Corvus Raaf
Adieu...
Not sure you can make it any clearerReverance said:
Derisive Umbaran
[member="Corvus Raaf"]
That rule stipulates you contact your opponent beforehand to establish a line of communication. Makes things easier for the fight. It does not say you require their permission to engage them.
Let me be clear- you failed to make it a rule for this invasion that all fights are 1v1 unless otherwise agreed upon. That's what the Primeval did on Ziost and it worked wonders for them. It was in their invasion terms. It's not in the terms for this invasion.
That rule stipulates you contact your opponent beforehand to establish a line of communication. Makes things easier for the fight. It does not say you require their permission to engage them.
Let me be clear- you failed to make it a rule for this invasion that all fights are 1v1 unless otherwise agreed upon. That's what the Primeval did on Ziost and it worked wonders for them. It was in their invasion terms. It's not in the terms for this invasion.
Sage Bane
Gazing into the abyss
[member="Mantic Dorn"] [member="Darth Carach"]
Taking this discussion to PM with the relevant writers. Having the discussion in the OOC isn't helping keep the friction down.
Taking this discussion to PM with the relevant writers. Having the discussion in the OOC isn't helping keep the friction down.
Corvus Raaf
Adieu...
[member="Adekos"]
LOL - I didn't make any rules. I'm not an FA.
This board used to run on the minimum of rules and common sense and courtesy applied.
It's a sad indictment of CHAOS if we have to create rules to manage the minority' that lack either.
Not a criticism of you BTW. But to extend your logic, I'm not aware there's a rule that says you HAVE to accept a new writer into your 1:1
LOL - I didn't make any rules. I'm not an FA.
This board used to run on the minimum of rules and common sense and courtesy applied.
It's a sad indictment of CHAOS if we have to create rules to manage the minority' that lack either.
Not a criticism of you BTW. But to extend your logic, I'm not aware there's a rule that says you HAVE to accept a new writer into your 1:1
Kamon's OOC
Well-Known Member
That's because there isn't one. Many people will roll with the punches, but as Reverence pointed out that you are to engage in conversation OOC before posting in a fight, Carach kind of didn't adhere to that, which gives Mantic grounds for saying no, and telling him to back off.Corvus Raaf said:[member="Adekos"]
LOL - I didn't make any rules. I'm not an FA.
This board used to run on the minimum of rules and common sense and courtesy applied.
It's a sad indictment of CHAOS if we have to create rules to manage the minority' that lack either.
Not a criticism of you BTW. But to extend your logic, I'm not aware there's a rule that says you HAVE to accept a new writer into your 1:1
It's common courtesy, people. Joining the tail end of the fight in effort to sway it (duel sniping) is bad form.
Sage Bane
Gazing into the abyss
We've taken the issue to PM guys. No need to stir it further.
In case it's unclear to folks how invasions work, these invasion terms (and their lack of opposing writer permission for duels) were agreed upon by BOTH factions before the invasion started. If there was an issue with it, it should have been solved before the terms were released.
That would be the way to ensure the least amount of confusion over this issue IMO.
In case it's unclear to folks how invasions work, these invasion terms (and their lack of opposing writer permission for duels) were agreed upon by BOTH factions before the invasion started. If there was an issue with it, it should have been solved before the terms were released.
That would be the way to ensure the least amount of confusion over this issue IMO.
B E A C O N
Lol.
Conceited
If the invasion is drawing to a close, which side has won?
[member="Nerius"]
I'm about to reply. Hopefully you won LOLdodge me for a 4th time
[member="Nerius"]
I'm about to reply. Hopefully you won LOLdodge me for a 4th time
Similar threads
